startthat.work home

Challenge

These techniques look for what is wrong with a line of reasoning: listing and testing its assumptions, building the strongest case against it, having two teams argue competing views, modelling how an adversary would decide, or working out pathways to an unlikely but serious event. They examine the findings and never the request, because only you change the request.

15 techniques. Open one to see what it does, when it fits and what it needs from your material.

IDTechniquePurposeEvidence status
CH-01Key assumptions check (assumptions check)Lists the stated and unstated premises of the current line, challenges each, and produces a refined assumptions register with the conditions that would invalidate each assumption.Documented
CH-02Strategic assumption surfacing and testing (SAST)Lists each interested group assumptions, rates them, has opposing groups debate them in four stages, and produces a rated assumptions register.Documented
CH-03Devil's advocacyBuilds the strongest case against the dominant view or plan, starting from its most vulnerable assumptions, and produces a labelled devil advocate finding.Documented
CH-04Team A and Team BHas two teams each build the best case for a competing view and debate before a jury of peers, and produces competing papers and debate findings.Documented
CH-05Red team analysis (red team, red cell)Models how an adversary or other actor would decide by reasoning in that actor first-person voice, or examines a plan from outside the planning team, and produces first-person memos predicting decisions.Documented
CH-06High-impact and low-probability analysis Also serves: Project forward.Works out plausible pathways to an unlikely but consequential event, with triggers and indicators, and produces pathways and an indicator list.Documented
CH-07What if analysis Also serves: Project forward.Assumes an unexpected event has occurred, explains how it could have come about, and produces scenarios with indicators and consequence assessments.Documented
CH-08Premortem (prospective hindsight, inversion) Also serves: Project forward.Asks a team to assume the plan has already failed and to write the reasons, and produces a grouped list of failure reasons and draft assumptions.Practice
CH-09Structured self-critiqueAsks about sources of uncertainty, evidence, gaps, critical assumptions and alternative hypotheses, and produces a written critique of one own analysis.Documented
CH-10Rapoport's rules (fair restatement of an opposing position) Also serves: Compare.Requires a fair restatement of the opposing position, a list of points of agreement and of what was learned before any rebuttal, and produces a restatement and an agreement list.Documented
CH-11Steelmanning Also serves: Compare.Builds the strongest version of a position the analyst disagrees with, responds to it, and produces a strengthened opposing argument and a response.Practice
CH-12Socratic questioning (Paul and Elder's six question types)Asks a sequence of questions that expose unclear terms, hidden assumptions and unsupported claims, and produces a record of questions and answers and a draft assumptions register.Documented
CH-13Cognitive bias checks and debiasing (including consider-the-opposite)Runs a conclusion through a list of known judgement biases, applies a counter-procedure, and produces a checklist of marked items where disconfirming evidence should be sought.Unconfirmed
CH-14Structured brainstormingGenerates and clusters many ideas about a focal question before any critique and produces clustered, prioritised ideas.Documented
CH-15Group process safeguards (everyone speaks once before anyone speaks twice, mindguarding)Controls how a group forms views, with each person contributing in turn, leaders withholding early preferences and evaluators rotating, and produces independent individual views.Documented