Decompose and map
These techniques give a topic structure: an issue tree whose branches do not overlap, a tree of the sub-claims that must all be true, a taxonomy, a value chain, or an affinity diagram that groups many comments or quotes into clusters. Use them when the material is large or loosely organised and you need a structure before you can judge anything.
21 techniques. Open one to see what it does, when it fits and what it needs from your material.
| ID | Technique | Purpose | Evidence status |
|---|---|---|---|
| DM-01 | MECE decomposition and issue tree (mutually exclusive, collectively exhaustive; logic tree, problem tree; related: work breakdown structure) | Divides a topic into sub-parts that do not overlap and together cover the whole, repeated at each level, and produces a tree. | Practice |
| DM-02 | Hypothesis tree (hypothesis-driven decomposition, claim decomposition) | Splits a claim into the sub-claims that must all be true for it to be true and produces a tree of claims that goes into a claims register. | Unconfirmed |
| DM-03 | Morphological analysis (Zwicky box, general morphological analysis) Also serves: Project forward. | Lists the parameters of a topic and the possible values of each, removes value pairs judged inconsistent, and produces a grid and a reduced set of consistent configurations. | Documented |
| DM-04 | Value chain analysis (Porter) | Divides the activities of one business unit into five primary and four support activities and produces a value chain showing where cost and differentiation concentrate. | Documented |
| DM-05 | Taxonomy building (classification scheme, typology, controlled vocabulary) | Builds a scheme of classes from observable characteristics, assigns items to the classes and produces a hierarchy and a draft codebook. | Documented |
| DM-06 | Affinity diagram (KJ method) | Groups many recorded items, such as survey comments or interview quotes, into clusters that form from the relationships among the items, and produces labelled clusters. | Documented |
| DM-07 | Lens application (sorting claims by a classification lens, for example input versus outcome) | Sorts a set of claims or measures by chosen categories, such as input or outcome, and produces a table of claims by category. | Unconfirmed |
| DM-08 | Two by two matrix (quadrant analysis) Also serves: Assess actors, options and risks; Project forward. | Places items on two chosen dimensions so that each falls into one of four cells and produces a quadrant table. | Unconfirmed |
| DM-09 | PESTLE (political, economic, social, technological, legal, environmental; the shorter PEST omits legal and environmental; outside-in thinking) | Sorts external factors into political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental categories and produces a categorised list. | Documented |
| DM-10 | SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats) | Sorts factors into internal strengths and weaknesses and external opportunities and threats and produces a two by two matrix. | Documented |
| DM-11 | Porter's Five Forces (industry structure analysis) | Rates rivalry, new entrants, substitutes, buyer power and supplier power and produces a five-force diagram with each force rated. | Documented |
| DM-12 | Cynefin framework | Classifies a situation, or each part of it, as clear, complicated, complex, chaotic or confusion by the relation of cause and effect and produces a domain assignment. | Documented |
| DM-13 | System archetypes (limits to growth, shifting the burden, fixes that fail, and others) | Matches an observed behaviour pattern to a recurring feedback structure and produces a named pattern with the loop structure to change. | Documented |
| DM-14 | Leverage points (Meadows' twelve places to intervene in a system) | Ranks types of intervention in a system from least to most effective and produces an ordered list showing the level at which a proposed intervention acts. | Documented |
| DM-15 | Wardley mapping | Positions the components of a service by visibility to the user and by evolution stage, with dependency lines, and produces a two-axis map. | Practice |
| DM-16 | Levels-of-analysis models (Marr's three levels, micro, meso and macro levels) | Examines a topic at several distinct levels, each answering a different kind of question, and produces findings organised by level. | Documented |
| DM-17 | Process mapping (flowcharts, swimlane diagrams, value stream maps) | Records the sequence of steps, inputs, outputs and responsible roles in a process and produces a flow diagram showing handoffs, delays and rework loops. | Unconfirmed |
| DM-18 | Design structure matrix (dependency structure matrix) | Records which element depends on or supplies which in a square matrix, reorders it to reveal clusters or sequence, and produces a reordered matrix. | Documented |
| DM-19 | Causal loop diagram Also serves: Trace cause and test claims. | Draws variables and signed causal links so that reinforcing and balancing loops and delays can be identified, and produces a diagram with loop labels. | Documented |
| DM-20 | Stock and flow modelling (system dynamics, including simulation) Also serves: Project forward. | Represents accumulations that change only through inflows and outflows and, when simulated, produces a diagram and simulated time paths. | Documented |
| DM-21 | Social network analysis (sociogram, network analysis) Also serves: Assess actors, options and risks. | Represents actors as nodes and relationships as ties, measures structure with graph metrics, and produces a sociogram, an entity table and metrics. | Documented |